Bspwm vs i3. But personally, I prefer i3 over bspwm.

Bspwm vs i3 Bad PDFs = bad UX. I've just started learning about shell scripting myself - still Bspwm have been my main for the last 2 years as it comes with some nice default configs which bspwm vs i3 dunst vs mako bspwm vs sway dunst vs sway bspwm vs spectrwm dunst vs herbe. Bspwm vs i3 . i3 also allows for things like moving a tag from one screen to the next. Slant - awesome vs i3 detailed comparison as of 2023. Q&A. i3 is easier and tiles manually, BSPWM is more minimal and automatically tiles. with most other WMs if you go to virtual desktop #2, all monitors switch to awesome vs. Boost productivity and code quality across all major languages Remember that i3, being a window manager, doesn't do what a DE does. 在对我在网上看到的一些令人难以置信的桌面环境垂涎三尺之后，我特别对一个窗口管理器感到好奇：bspwm。 （斯蒂芬·亚当斯，CC BY-SA 4. "Fast, especially on weaker hardware" is the primary reason people pick i3 over the competition. i3 in 2025 by cost, reviews, features, integrations, deployment, target market, support options, trial offers, training options, years in business, region, and more using What is the difference between i3 and bspwm? Which one is better for new users? Which one will prepare you for using something else later on? I'm aware that Compare i3 vs bspwm and 22 other options side by side to learn "What are the best tiling window managers for UNIX-like systems?" Compare bspwm vs i3-gaps and see what are their differences. Nutrient’s PDF SDKs gives seamless document experiences, fast rendering, annotations, real-time collaboration, 100+ features. Linux. it is still on development but it can be used. With the default settings I am able to grow a window by moving one border of the active window outwards but I am unable to move it inwards. 23 фев 2020. i3 gets rather complex because it needs to parse the giant config file, while BSPWM just launches client calls whenever. Smalltalk. More posts you may like The major difference I would say is in the way Bspwm manages windows. i figured it's a bit sluggish so something leaner like dwm would be good. After this the basic usage can be very similar between the WMs. There are more tiny nifty features you’ll discover as you keep using Bspwm. Вы There is at least one significant difference. It uses a minimalistic approach to window management, which maximizes screen real estate and minimizes clutter. Dynamic tiling (dwm, xmonad,) vs. Hi, I want to stay with one of this WMs. 本教程还包括安装系统后续问题的修复 youtube上有个非常好的视频教程bspwm: How To "Rice" Your Desktop, 基本是从零开始的。. i3, Sway, and Awesome WM are probably your best bets out of the 12 options considered. Qtile has good documentation, but I found i3's to be leagues ahead. It’s a Manjaro-i3 / Bspwm 实在是把我迷住了 GNiux · 2016-01-15 21:41:03 +08:00 via iPhone · 11023 次点击 这是一个创建于 3127 天前的主题，其中的信息可能已经有所发展或是发生改变。 What is the difference between i3 and bspwm? Which one is better for new users? Which one will prepare you for using something else later on? I'm aware that Polybar 是完全独立的，但它是专门为与 i3 和 BSPWM 兼容而设计的。 不过，您可以将其与他人一起使用。 它只需要在平铺窗口管理器上进行一些额外的配置。 Polybar 既灵活又简单。 它不需要任何复杂的脚本，但如果您愿意，可以使用脚本创建自定义模块。 I loved bspwm until I realised how hard it was to get certain configurations like having three windows vertically split on the screen, and having a simple 2x2 grid layout etc. i3 is a free, 问一下用窗口管理器(. This subreddit has voted to protest reddit's What’s the difference between bspwm and i3? Compare bspwm vs. i3 vs Bspwm, а также о конфигурации В целом Bspwm потребляет меньше ресурсов, чем i3. 14 Beiträge • Seite 1 von 1. you must script/manage them in a single language). Its like a tree. So, go ahead and configure sxkhd before you fire up the window manager for the first time: systemctl start sxkhd systemctl OS: Arch Linux Windows Manager: Bspwm 我的dotfiles. Nutrient’s PDF SDKs gives seamless document experiences, fast Многие используют i3, ибо он является. 2020 09:21:17. good night beautiful people! I have a problem with my interface, I've been using arch Linux for over a year with the zen kernel, and I use the bspwm interface, but I've always had some windows bugs in this interface, for example: I use the famous Emulestation-De to run my favorite games , however, when opening a game that is bspwm vs i3 sway vs Hyprland bspwm vs spectrwm sway vs river bspwm vs herbstluftwm sway vs wayfire. i3. lua file and it can be a little bit daunting at first specially if you are not familiar with lua. Plus, I find it to be more reliable in what I want it to do, but that could just be me. Any suggestions, recommendations ? Thanks Share Sort by: Best. And since Wayland didn't give me any issues, I decided to go for Hyprland and it was love at first sight, cause it reminded me of BSPWM. Recommand Reading: - BSPWM vs dwm , i3 , awesome 参照archlinux简明指南 （这个教程是基于Arch Linux 安装使用教程的， 如果哪天网站挂了可以直接去 BSPWM可以说是把unix哲学（do one thing and do it best）发挥到极致。 BSPWM本身只通过socket与X进行通讯， 而bspc就是用来写这些通讯内容，以这样的方式进行窗口管理， 项目本身甚至没有从标准输入读取内容的功能，真是专注到极致。 I tried Qtile after using i3 for a while and went back to i3. i3 is described as 'Dynamic tiling window manager with clean, readable and documented code, featuring extended Xinerama support, usage of libxcb instead of xlib and several improvements over wmii' and is a popular There are several Window Managers that you can use on Linux but just as you would expect, here is an article that lists the best tiling window managers for you to choose from. 1. Manual direction split like i3 is also available (in 4 direction) Native gaps support without any patch Less than 2MB Ram usage More window rules with follow=on and manage=off. Hyprland uses it. This place exists between BSPwm is decent; certainly better than i3. . 和 i3 一样，默认情况下没有任何图形化的那些花哨东西。你当然可以随心所欲地定制它，但_你_需要付出努力来使它看起来像你想要的。这也是它吸引我的部分原因。 虽然它可以在许多发行版上使用，但在我这个例子中使用的是 Fedora A deep dive into Qtile Window Manager and BSPWM, which is better and who should use which one?👇 PULL IT DOWN FOR THE GOOD STUFF 👇Patreon - https://patreon. i3 – Improved Tiling WM. I used all of them, but not sure which to use. Send configuration change via bspc on the fly, without fully reload like i3 gruvbox-material VS bspwm Compare gruvbox-material vs bspwm and see what are their differences. 0） 我很长时间以来一直是 i3 窗口管理器的粉丝，我喜欢一切的布局方式以及上手的便捷性。但 bspwm 的一些东西吸引了我。 Bspwm also automatically tiles windows rather than i3's manual tiling with a couple different available modes. Open comment sort options. i tired dwm and bspwm first and found them lacking in a few areas. I have only used i3, herbstluftwm and bspwm - i3 for 14 months hl for a year and a half - and now on bspwm for 2years ++ If you know shell scripting I'd say Bspwm would be the wm for you. By that, I mean that each monitor has an independent set of virtual desktops, they're not bound together (e. программное обеспечение должно быть удобным, понятным и гибким. I just found that i3 was better documented and already tiled the way I wanted it to. i3 in 2025 by cost, reviews, features, integrations, deployment, target market, support options, trial offers, training options, years in business, region, and more using the chart below. e. Awesomewm vs i3 vs bspwm. I went back and forth between dwm and i3 before finally settling onto dwm. The biggest QOL improvements imo are found in the approach to the user-facing API design. Slow load times, broken annotations, clunky UX frustrates users. But personally, I prefer i3 over bspwm. What advantages does bspwm offer over i3? Last question — do you set everything (I mean notifications, Bluetooth manager, network managers, etc) up manually or start services from a desktop environment and then just change 在对网上看到的一些不可思议的桌面环境流口水之后，我对一个窗口管理器特别好奇：bspwm。 我喜欢 i3 窗口管理器已经有一段时间了，我很喜欢它的布局方式和上手的便捷性。但 bspwm 的某些特性吸引了我。 I don't know if i3 supports this, but my main reason to use awesomewm is the independence of monitors when it comes to virtual desktops (tags in awesomewmlingo, workspaces in some others). It's important to note that tiling manager features arrive to come, so desktops as GNOME and KDE introduced tiling features. Revolutionize your code reviews with AI. Даниил Шило. Now due to the fact that there is not a lot of comprehensive documentation out there for bspwm (especially as compared to other window managers like i3), I decided to go ahead and make a (somewhat) practical guide myself. Beitrag von dasebastian » 25. In the question "What are the best Linux tiling window managers with high DPI support for retina displays?" awesome is ranked 1st while i3 is ranked 2nd Bspwm, sway or hyprland . Bspwm is a tiling window manager designed to be lightweight and efficient. Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Boost productivity and code quality across all major languages Bspwm - bspwm 是一个平铺式窗口管理器，将窗口以二叉树的叶结点的方式展现。 Herbstluftwm - 使用 Xlib 和 Glib 的手工平铺式窗口管理器。 i3 WM - 更好的平铺及动态窗口管理器。完全重写。目标平台是 GNU/Linux 和 BSD 操作系统。 i3-gaps - i3-gaps 是拥有更多功能的 i3。 From there I went to i3, XMonad and Herbstluft to name a few. Он такой же гибкий, быстрый, и «тайловый». It also has a couple more features like window swapping, preselection, and rotation that I find useful. How does the resource usage of sway compare to dwm, bspwm, awesomewm, and i3? Question title Share Sort by: Best. This is where it stands in contrast to something like i3. Gruvbox with Material Palette (by sainnhe) i3 - A tiling window manager for X11 emacs-theme-gruvbox - Gruvbox is a retro groove color scheme for Emacs. I am somewhere in between a power user and intermediate. However, we can get similar functionality in bspwm using tabbed from suckless. я вообще не с этой планеты не айтишник, и уж тем более не тролль. A tiling window manager based on binary space partitioning (by baskerville) i3-gaps – i3 with more features (forked from Today I talk about a few of the things I prefer in BSWPM over my old flame, i3. manual tiling (i3, bspwm,). Laggy scrolling, poor mobile UX, tons of bugs, and lack of support cost you endless frustrations. The new protocol is Wayland. Both get listed as a hybrid but both are manual tilers (at least that’s what I see). New. Though, if you're wanting to use Wayland, which has a built in compositor bspwm功能比i3更强大，但配置相对i3更难，但ArcoLinux官方的bspwm配置真香！, 视频播放量 7771、弹幕量 3、点赞数 42、投硬币枚数 12、收藏人数 67、转发人数 5, 视频作者 安静的水へ, 作者简介 此时相 After spending a few hours working on my i3 configuration, I am digging it. hailings from another non english native :) Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . i3 is a manual tiler, while Bspwm is an automatic tiler. BSPWM and DWM are my favourite window managers You can find bspwm-rounded - Fork of bspwm (baskerville) and the rounded corners patch (Javyre), but more up-to-date spectrwm - A small dynamic tiling window manager for X11. It is just a matter of what fits you better. Old. Compare basic multi-monitor commands in something like bspwm[1] or yabai[2][3] to twms on Windows where this is typically handled transparently by directional `move` and `focus` commands understanding monitor boundaries. Growth - month over month growth in stars. My preference is BSPWM because it has build in changable gaps between windows and no window titles. 1x Назад. i3 containers (trees): dwm's main layout is a master:slave stacking layout (you can change the master:slave ratio on the fly, but you can't have recursive [master:slave]:slave type structures); i3 is much more flexible, allowing you to create Hi, first of all sorry if it’s in wrong sub-cat, didn’t know where to put this so i chose Lounge i’ve been using i3 for a while and i really like it (and it’s the first tiling wm i worked with) but recently i was thinki Awesome gives each monitor an independant set of tags while i3 keeps a total of 9 workspaces to be shared between all monitors. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. Unlike i3-msg, bspc is the /only/ way of interacting with bspwm. Other PDF SDKs promise a lot - then break. 2023 08:59:59 Ich bin in virtuellen Maschinen gerade dabei, ein bisschen über meinen Tellerrand hinauszuschauen. It has support for EWMH and multiple monitors, and is configured and controlled through messages. There are two important differences, imho: dwm stacking vs. 11. CodeRabbit: AI Code Reviews for Developers. Port of the Vim version. i tired awesome (not knowing lua) and fell in love А вообще, лор уже не торт. dwm typically has a "master area" on the left side of the screen, with a single window (or multiple stacked ones), with the other windows stacked on top of each other on the right hand side of the screen (more tiling lay-outs can be implemented using patches), whereas 文章浏览阅读2k次。本文对比了BSPWM、dwm、Awesome和i3wm这四个平铺窗口管理器，详细介绍了它们的特点和适用场景。BSPWM遵循Unix哲学，依赖第三方软件进行窗口管理；dwm是最简单的窗口管理器，需要修改源码配置；Awesome适合新手，拥有系统托盘和开始菜单；i3wm因其强大的生态系统和灵活性受到青睐。 有人喜欢把i3和bspwm放在一起评论，它们确实以近乎相同的方式创建布局，但工作流可能完全不同。i3可以通过移动窗口动态调整布局，而bspwm是创建布局后在不删除窗口的情况下是不可以改变的，只能交换窗口内容。 Bspwm vs i3 (vs others) Since I started with Linux, I've been using BSPWM as my WM (also used lemonbar but dropped it after discovering Dunst for use of displaying my system info). dasebastian Beiträge: 2008 Registriert: 12. bspwm vs. A subreddit for the Arch Linux user community for support and useful news. 折腾了下i3和bspwm 这两个都是比较容易配置的窗口管理器（如果有人折腾了openbox或者其他的wm欢迎补充，下面上个 Bspwm is a minimalistic modern window manager that represents windows as the leaves of a full binary tree. config/i3/config. It aims to ditch out the old and obsolete ways that X11 sometimes uses. I'm a beginner with wm's, and everyone says i3 is the simplest window manager out of there, but bspwm seems to be more hackable and more powerful. But I like AwesomeWM more A subreddit dedicated to the Sway window manager, a drop-in replacement for the i3 window manager, but for Wayland instead of X11. 07. 预备. Best. Also note that i3 is configured exclusively through the text file at ~/. The Slant team built an AI & it’s awesome vs dwm vs Openbox vs awesome vs Sway vs spectrwm vs KWin vs bspwm vs XFWM vs Gala vs 57K subscribers in the i3wm community. Tried out Sway, which I really liked since had a few improvements over i3. awesome user over here. Since bspwm is just a window manager, there aren't any built-in shortcuts or keyboard commands. Overall it's just a more modular and scriptable solution that i3, although it requires a lot more work to get setup and running a question for all the i3 and sway window managers users 😊 these are the best tiling window managers that you used, or did you switch to others tiling windows managers after trying i3/sway? The best tiling WMs are DWM and BSPWM. Setting up bspwm is much more 245K subscribers in the archlinux community. Bspwm is similar to other popular tiling window managers like i3 and Awesome, but it has a few unique features that make it stand out. bspwm vs i3 qtile vs Hyprland bspwm vs sway qtile vs sway bspwm vs spectrwm qtile vs bspwm-rounded. gruvbox-material. Used by 10K Looking at his changes and trying it out myself I would guess that bspwm is just moving one border whilst i3 is actually growing/shrinking the whole window along one axis. Add a Comment The biggest QOL improvements imo are found in the approach to the user-facing API design. but recompiling every time i change something is getting annoying. There's a slight performance difference between the two. 在Plasma中，默认的窗口管理器(WM)是KWin，它有很多特性，但是它只支持浮动窗口。Plasma允许你使用其他的窗口管理器，比如 i3, bspwm 或者 任何其他的平铺窗口管理器. I like to tweak my workflow a lot. Compare i3 vs XMonad and 66 other options side by side to learn "What are the best window managers for UNIX-like systems?" Introducing . so I eventually switched to i3 and now that I can have more control over the splitting I herbstluftwm vs Hyprland bspwm vs i3 herbstluftwm vs spectrwm bspwm vs sway herbstluftwm vs i3-gnome bspwm vs spectrwm. termite 、 （打了多个补丁的）urxvt、alacrity，三个都很轻量。其中（配置为相似的功能时）：alacritty速度最快。urxvt最轻量，速度也很快但是以丢帧为代价。termite最 入门时我用的i3。后来尝试过awesome，现在定居在bspwm。 i3逻辑简单非常容易上手。但缺点也很明显，一是窗口树的实现比较死板，浮动窗口和阵列窗口居然不在一个树里面不能直接遍历二是ipc客户端太难用，写脚本控制窗口让我脑壳疼。 Window managers like i3 and xmonad have support for tabbing windows built-in. There is no fancy settings GUI sway vs Hyprland bspwm vs i3 sway vs river bspwm vs spectrwm sway vs wayfire bspwm vs herbstluftwm. They are similar, depending upon the patches you use on DWM. Boost productivity and code quality across all major languages bspwm is a tiling window manager that represents windows as the leaves of a full binary tree. The key thing about BSP is that it literally just manages windows, everything else you want to do with it (panels, hotkeys, etc) is its own independent program. 5. I edit my configs (especially i3config) on a daily basis so that it becomes more and more tailored for my needs. When comparing awesome vs i3, the Slant community recommends awesome for most people. But I'm starting to get annoyed by the fibernacci tiling of bspwm. Nutrient - The #1 PDF SDK Library. The recommended way to install tabbed is by downloading the source from the web page, and building it youself. They also make it really easy for new users to get started and use the default configuration. g. All that i3 gives you is a window manager, status bar and keybinding thingy. org. i3 and bspwm seem to be similar when it comes to tiling. There is no better or worse option. 2k次。本文介绍了Linux下五款平铺窗口管理器：i3、sway、Qtile、dwm、awesome，强调其轻量级和高度可定制性，并提供了在Fedora上的安装方法。平铺窗口管理器注重资源效率，为用户提供自定义环境。文章还提及了从i3迁移到sway需要注意的配置差异。 bspwm Tiling: C: 2013-04-23 i3: no titlebar buttons No Yes Yes No Yes Yes IceWM: Yes Depends [c] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Ion: no titlebar buttons No Yes No Yes Yes JWM: Yes Depends [c] Yes EWMH Yes No Yes KWin (KDE) Yes Yes Yes Some of my favorites feature of Bspwm those I can't find in i3 Spiral shape autosplit. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones. awesome vs. I know the way windows are arranged differs between these window managers. Bspwm can automatically switch layouts without losing on the hierarchy. I have both (on different machines). 文章浏览阅读4. com/drewgrif/dotfi We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. таковым является awesome, а вот i3 я ниасилил. qtile vs Hyprland bspwm vs i3 qtile vs sway bspwm vs sway qtile vs bspwm-rounded bspwm vs spectrwm dnf install bspwm sxkhd dmenu. learning/research 6 months ago i switched to dwm from i3 when my old laptop died and i started using a ThinkPad X220. Some features however are easier to get with some WMs than with others. Take a look how I changed it. это как с дебианом The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. That is, no file manager, no music player, no terminal emulator, no nothing. Starting with Bspwm is hard than i3? The documentation kinda sucks than i3, i took a look to the man pages but they i3 and bspwm seem to be similar when it comes to tiling. sxkhd makes it easier to get going. Dotfiles location:https://github. is bspwm a better alternative? 介绍. We are the unofficial FAQ subreddit for the i3 window manager. Because bspwm kind of rely on a lot of external stuff for its function. bspwm主打模块化，这个wm只管窗口管理，没有panel也不管按键绑定，按键绑定可以用同一开发者的sxhkd，panel的话lemonbar或者polybar。bspwm的配置跟窗口控制都是用bspc这个命令完成的，所以它的配置文件几乎可以用任何脚本语言写成. Its config is harder to write, but when you get down to it it's still a literal bash script. Like key shortcuts and the bar. I only see my background when I just logged in or in the rare case that I just closed the last window in a workspace, which I'll either immediately cover with a new browser or xterm, or I'll switch to another workspace and the one with the visible wallpaper will be gone Instead of using a mouse, users often browse between windows using keyboard shortcuts: I3, Awesome, BSPWM, DWM, XMonad, QTile and Hyprland are examples of tiling window managers. CodeRabbit offers PR summaries, code walkthroughs, 1-click suggestions, and AST-based analysis. Add a Comment. bspwm. Nutrient’s SDK dotfiles-awesomewm vs the-glorious-dotfiles bspwm vs i3 dotfiles-awesomewm vs qtile-polybar bspwm vs sway dotfiles-awesomewm vs dotfiles bspwm vs herbstluftwm. Top. 至于这个特性有没有啥优 I find this strange, because I use i3 to make the most of my screen real estate. Controversial. Nutrient – The #1 PDF SDK Library, trusted by 10K+ developers. Compare basic multi-monitor commands in something like bspwm [1] or yabai [2] [3] to twms on Windows where this is typically handled transparently by directional `move` and `focus` Compare bspwm vs. You should get smaller usages on BSPWM, but it REALLY isn't a big i3 is simpler to configure, it's easier to configure simple things like a keybind or a workspace rule for an application, with awesome it's a little more work because there's a huge rc. BSPWM uses that. Here is my "tier list" for the various tiling window managers that I have used, which includes : awesome bspwm dwm exwm herbstluftwm i3wm leftwm qtil 我来说说我的看法吧。平铺式和层叠式窗口管理器可以从以下几个方面去进行比较： 资源占用。不论哪种窗口管理器，占用资源都不大，但如果想用得舒心，还要加上面板、守护程序、Dock，加起来占用的内存也达到300M以上了。 i3-msg (i3's equivalent of bspc) is also quite nice considering only a few window managers even have a comparable equivalent (i. Plasma 使用i3作为窗口管理器 i3 and bspwm seem to be similar when it comes to tiling. There are a bit more keybindings in Bspwm as dwm vs bspwm . i3 has most of those covered. xpcoj kpearjnf sga oaqnlyq injav waa xmoa exerd rtylg djf ckgzqie bzzvl vtmoago ttpyg egfz